Current:Home > InvestJudge won’t block Georgia prosecutor disciplinary body that Democrats fear is aimed at Fani Willis -MoneyBase
Judge won’t block Georgia prosecutor disciplinary body that Democrats fear is aimed at Fani Willis
View
Date:2025-04-13 06:51:35
ATLANTA (AP) — A Georgia judge has denied a preliminary challenge to block a commission created to discipline and remove state prosecutors, finding that it doesn’t violate the U.S. or state constitution.
Fulton County Superior Court Judge Paige Reese Whitaker on Tuesday rejected the request for an injunction against Georgia’s Prosecuting Attorneys Qualifications Commission, which Republican lawmakers revived this year after creating it in 2023.
Democrats fear the commission has one primary goal: derailing Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis ' prosecution of former President Donald Trump. Republicans, though, say it is needed to discipline so-called rogue prosecutors who are refusing to enforce laws.
Republican Gov. Brian Kemp signed legislation last year creating the commission, but it couldn’t begin operating because the state Supreme Court refused to approve rules governing its conduct. The justices said they had “grave doubts” about the high court’s ability to regulate the decisions made by district attorneys.
Lawmakers then removed the requirement for court approval, a change Kemp signed into law. The commission began operating April 1.
Republicans in Tennessee, Missouri, Indiana, Pennsylvania and Florida have pushed back on prosecutors who announced they would pursue fewer drug possession cases and shorter prison sentences as a matter of criminal justice reform.
The Georgia challenge was filed by Sherry Boston, the district attorney in the Atlanta suburb of DeKalb County; Jared Williams of Augusta and neighboring Burke County; and Jonathan Adams of Butts, Lamar and Monroe counties south of Atlanta. Adams is a Republican, the others are Democrats.
Although the underlying lawsuit is still pending before Whitaker, she expressed grave doubts about its arguments that the law violates prosecutorial discretion, a fundamental of the American judicial system through which prosecutors decide what charges to bring and how severe of a sentence to seek.
The prosecutors say the law violates Georgia’s constitutional separation of powers by requiring district attorneys to review every single case on its individual merits. District attorneys argue that they should be able to reject prosecution of whole categories of crimes as a matter of policy. But Whitaker found that the requirement that every case be reviewed “does not meaningfully impair prosecutorial discretion.”
She was also skeptical of the claim that state lawmakers are improperly intruding on the judicial branch by regulating prosecutors.
“Because the Georgia Constitution expressly authorizes the General Assembly to impose statutory duties on district attorneys and to create the grounds and process to discipline or remove district attorneys, there is no violation of the state Constitution’s separation of powers clause,” Whitaker wrote.
Whitaker also rejected the district attorneys’ claim that the law violates federal and state constitutional guarantees of freedom of speech by restricting what matters of public concern district attorneys can talk about when running for office. She said the law doesn’t cover such political speech. She also said there’s no proof that the commission is to blame for already chilling prosecutors’ speech, as the district attorneys have claimed. The judge said there was no evidence the commission has started investigating any prosecutor, much less started disciplinary proceedings against any.
Whitaker also said she was likely to reject a claim that the commission had improperly adopted its rules.
State Senate President Pro Tem John Kennedy, a Macon Republican who has supported the law, called on the district attorneys to drop the case after their preliminary loss.
“To continue this challenge is an injustice to crime victims in our communities as well as to Georgia taxpayers having to shoulder the expense of this frivolous case,” Kennedy said in a statement. “This is the second time these plaintiff-prosecutors have failed in court to block the law. Maybe it’s time to realize that they have a losing argument.”
State Sen. Randy Robertson, a Cataula Republican who sponsored the law, rejected claims that the law improperly curbs prosecutorial discretion.
“I understand how important it is for officials to exercise discretion but that does not mean they can simply ignore the law and allow crime to run rampant,” Robertson said in a statement.
Boston said that despite the setback, she and the other plaintiffs aren’t giving up and are committed to carrying the fight to the Georgia Supreme Court.
“We are committed to continuing our fight against this unconstitutional overreach by the state as our challenge makes its way through the courts,” Boston said in a statement.
veryGood! (2)
Related
- Could your smelly farts help science?
- Over 300,000 GMC, Chevrolet trucks recalled over concerns with tailgate's release system
- Patrick Mahomes lauds Iowa basketball star Caitlin Clark, says she will 'dominate' WNBA
- Bill Maher opens up about scrapped Kanye West interview: 'I wouldn't air that episode'
- Google unveils a quantum chip. Could it help unlock the universe's deepest secrets?
- House will vote on Homeland Security secretary impeachment: How did we get here, what does it mean?
- Deadly decade-long listeria outbreak linked to cojita and queso fresco from a California business
- NASA PACE launch livestream: Watch liftoff of mission to examine Earth's oceans
- Louvre will undergo expansion and restoration project, Macron says
- Judge wants answers after report that key witness in Trump fraud trial may plead guilty to perjury
Ranking
- Stamford Road collision sends motorcyclist flying; driver arrested
- Bill Maher opens up about scrapped Kanye West interview: 'I wouldn't air that episode'
- Alabama lawmakers begin session with votes on gambling and school vouchers ahead
- Miss Japan Winner Karolina Shiino Renounces Title After Alleged Affair
- Intel's stock did something it hasn't done since 2022
- Jury deliberations entering 2nd day in trial of Michigan school shooter’s mom
- We Found the Best Affordable Jewelry on Amazon That Looks High End
- South Carolina woman seeks clarity on abortion ban in lawsuit backed by Planned Parenthood
Recommendation
In ‘Nickel Boys,’ striving for a new way to see
Doctors face huge stigma about mental illness. Now there's an effort to change that
NTSB says bolts on Boeing jetliner were missing before a panel blew out in midflight last month
Man serving life in prison for 2014 death of Tucson teen faces retrial in killing of 6-year-old girl
Brianna LaPaglia Reveals The Meaning Behind Her "Chickenfry" Nickname
Andy Reid vs. Kyle Shanahan: Head coach rematch is fourth in Super Bowl history
Black churches, home for prayer and politics alike, get major preservation funds
'Put the dog back': Georgia family accuses Amazon driver of trying to steal puppy from yard